For many people, eyes are an extra sensitive part of the body and eye makeup like mascara can contribute to a number of reactions, including dry, itchy, puffy or running eyes. If you wear contact lenses or suffer from allergies, you might find your mascara is making things worse!
It’s time to say goodbye to itchy eyes without having to go about your day bare-lashed. The best mascaras for sensitive eyes are specifically formulated with hypoallergenic and natural ingredients.
Depending on your level of sensitivity, you don’t need to settle for low-punch natural formulas. You can still get the lashes of your dreams with some of the best hypoallergenic mascaras on the market.
What to Look for When Shopping for Hypoallergenic Mascara
Look for phrases like “hypoallergenic” and “ophthalmologist-tested”. Also do your research on the brand and what ingredients they use. Sometimes, brands promote their products as hypoallergenic even if they contain known allergens.
Industry leaders of hypoallergenic makeup include Clinique, on the higher end, and Almay, at the drugstore end.
Even the best mascara formulas for sensitive eyes can still cause irritation if you don’t use them properly.
Best Practices to Avoid Mascara Irritation for Sensitive Eyes
No matter which brand you pick, make sure that you remove the mascara before bed. Be thorough yet gentle!
Also make sure you rotate your old mascara out. Keep it only for a maximum of 4 months before you start a new bottle. Most mascaras that are allergy and sensitive eye friendly don’t include preservatives.
While preservatives are a known irritant, they also play a huge role in keeping mascara lasting longer.
If you want a win-win, look for brands that have new formulas which work better. Look for less flakiness and drying up as mascaras that dry up can also cause irritation.
Note: If you think you’re having a serious reaction to any mascara, like swelling or a rash, consult your doctor before trying out any other mascaras.
12 Top Rated Hypoallergenic Mascara for Sensitive Eyes by Leading Experts
1. Chanel Le Volume de Chanel Mascara
Achieve a luscious look with just one stroke. If you’re looking for instant volume, this one’s for you. It includes natural beeswax so say goodbye to itchy eyes and hello to long lasting volume.
2. Lancôme Hypnôse Drama Instant Full Volume Mascara
Condition your lashes with a great waterproof formula. Fragrance-free, allergy tested and also great if you wear contacts!
3. Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara
Achieve a luscious look with just one stroke. If you’re looking for instant volume, this one’s for you. It includes natural beeswax so say goodbye to itchy eyes and hello to long lasting volume.
4. Clinique Lash Power Mascara
Smudge-proof, flake-free and awesome for sensitive eyes. It has less run-off than other brands and is also a tubular formula.
5. Alima Pure Natural Definition Mascara
While offering beautiful application, this mascara formula contains over 90% naturally derived ingredients. Extra bonus – it contains B5, natural oils and waxes to condition your lashes.
6. Almay Multi-Benefit Mascara
Build both length and volume while also keeping your precious lashes hydrated. You can also use this formula to stop your lashes drying up, which can only add to sensitive eye irritation.
7. Maybelline great Lash Mascara
Affordable, ophthalmologist tested and hypoallergenic. This product is also ideal for contact wearers and is a classic must-have product mascara lovers the world over can’t live without.
8. Pacifica Stellar Gaze Mascara
Infused with coconut oil and vitamin B for an extra dash of hydration. Each lash will be lengthened and strengthened while you perfect your jet black look. This formula also doesn’t clump or flake.
9. Tarte Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara
A vegan mascara formula that also contains vitamin C for lash conditioning – the ultimate secret to keeping them long and healthy. The mascara brush is also designed to help make your lashes look thicker and longer with minimal effort.
10. Eyeko Black Magic Mascara
A fusion of shea butter and keratin, this mascara hydrates and strengthens your lashes. The wand design is optimal for a single swipe application.
11. Kjaer Weis Mascara
Not only are 99.8% of the ingredients in this blend organic, they are also agriculturally derived ingredients. Safe for sensitive eyes and hypoallergenic. Also, while this product comes at a higher price point, you get discounted refills after you finish the initial lot.
12. L’Oreal Voluminous Mascara
A crucial in every makeup artist’s kit. Both the wand and formula are crafted to perfection, with extra care to ensure it never flakes or dries out. Key factors to avoid sensitive eye flare ups.
Our Top Pick
Natural Organic Mascara
by Endlessly Beautiful
Many people who are contact wearers, have sensitive eyes, or have never been able to wear mascara before, are raving about this product. It’s easy to remove at the end of the day with makeup remover, fractionated coconut oil, or just plain old soap and water. This is a vegan mascara that will nourish and condition your eyes while enhancing your natural lashes.
- 85% Organic Ingredients
- Non Toxic - Free of Harmful Chemicals
- Cruelty Free, Vegan
- Excellent Mascara for Sensitive Eyes
We love this mascara and believe many allergy sufferers will find it a refreshing option for sensitive eyes.
