best hypoallergenic eyeliner

Eyeliner Allergies & Hypoallergenic Eyeliner

Say goodbye to itchy eyes once and for good with hypoallergenic eyeliner! Here we list our expert’s top picks for the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes in 2020.
Say goodbye to itchy eyes once and for good with hypoallergenic eyeliner! Here we list our expert’s top picks for the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes in 2020.

Table of Contents

Hypoallergenic Homes is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other affiliate programs. We may earn income when you click on a link. Thank you for helping us deliver the best possible content for our readers.

Are you a fan of wearing eyeliner? If so, there’s nothing worse than having an allergic reaction to certain ingredients or preservatives in your eyeliner.

Here, we’ll provide you with everything you need to know about eyeliner allergies, and provide you with some hypoallergenic eyeliner product recommendations. We’ll even answer some frequently asked questions, read on to find out more!

Can You Be Allergic to Eyeliner?

Yes, you can be. More specifically, you could be allergic to preservatives or ingredients in the eyeliner.

What Are The Symptoms Of An Eyeliner Allergy?

Some symptoms of eyeliner allergies include:

hypoallergenic eye liner

Any discomfort you feel around your eyes either immediately after you put the eyeliner on or after a few hours could be signs of an eyeliner allergy. It is also possible to develop an allergy after months or years of using the same product.

How To Treat An Eyeliner Allergy

If your eyes are itchy or swollen, you can consider taking an oral antihistamine as it’ll target the chemical that causes allergic reaction symptoms – histamine. Alternatively, you can also take an oral corticosteroid that’ll help with inflammation. Though it can be difficult, you should also avoid scratching or rubbing your eyes.

What Ingredients In Eyeliner Cause Allergies?

When it comes to purchasing an eyeliner, there are some ingredients that you should avoid. They include:

Some ways to avoid purchasing eyeliner with harmful ingredients include carefully reading the labels. Waterproof eyeliners are especially prone to including harmful chemicals and additives so be extra vigilant when shopping for these.

Much like tattoo ink, black pigments used to give eyeliner that deep dark look are often derived from heavy metals, even toxic ones.

Best Hypoallergenic Eyeliners For Sensitive Eyes

If you’re looking to replace your eyeliner, here are some great options to get you started.

best hypoallergenic eyeliner brands

Physician’s Formula

The Physicians Formula hypoallergenic eyeliner comes in a set of three custom shades for you to create your own unique looks. It’s long-lasting, water and smudge-resistant, hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, and safe for those who wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes.

The Physicians Formula’s product range is created without any of the harsh ingredients that’s usually found in other personal care items and is recommended by allergists, dermatologists, and ophthalmologists.


Another great hypoallergenic eyeliner is Almay’s water-resistant eyeliner pencil that comes with a built-in sharpener. It comes in six shades and even has vitamin E added to the formula. Like all hypoallergenic eyeliners, Almay’s eyeliner is ophthalmologist tested, fragrance free and cruelty free.

La Pure

Last on the list, you’ve got La Pure’s Waterproof Eyeliner Stamp that’s made of natural ingredients such as shea butter, jojoba oil, canola oil, and other all-natural ingredients. You’ll also get a perfect consistent finish every time as you just have to stamp on your wings and you’re good to go. The eyeliner is also smudge-proof and water-resistant so you’ll have no problem wearing it throughout the day.

FAQS – You Ask, We Answer

Below are answers to some of the commonly asked questions we’ve received.

Honestly, it doesn’t really matter! You’re free to wear eyeliner until whatever age you’d like. Just be mindful of how your skin changes and any sensitivities that emerge, even with existing products you’ve been using.

You can if you want, but keeping it to the top lid has a more lifted and youthful effect. If you really want to add eyeliner to your bottom lash line, you should use a lighter color there in comparison to what you’re using on the top.

Heavy handed applications on the bottom lid can also lead to eye allergies as pigments of your mascara can more easily enter the eye socket.

Yes, it can happen. Even if you’ve been using the same eyeliner for a while, you could end up with allergic reactions such as itchiness and puffiness. Why does this happen? Simply because reactions to cosmetics can develop over time after repeated exposure.

Eyeliner and mascara usually go hand in hand, and you want to make sure that you’re not using mascara or eyeliner that’s been around for way too long. Hanging onto old makeup isn’t doing your eyes any favors and could result in eye infections – which is less than ideal.

Different types of microorganisms live on your facial skin – including your eyelids. When you use eyeliner, these microorganisms could cling onto your wand and end up in the tube. Eventually, they’ll build up and can end up spreading to your eyelids and eyeballs as you apply makeup.

Sound terrifying? That’s exactly why you should be tossing out your old eyeliner and purchasing a new one every 3 months. In the case of liquid eyeliner, you should replace it the moment you start hearing a popping noise when you open it.

So there you have it folks! The ultimate guide to avoiding eyeliner allergies and our list of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive eyes. Remember that you should always toss your eyeliner if you’ve had it for an extended period of time. After all, the last thing you’d want is to get an eye infection!

Picture of Hypoallergenic Homes

Hypoallergenic Homes

The Hypoallergenic Homes group of writers include qualified professionals in the fields of medicine and science. Articles are compiled and edited by our team of writers, then cross-checked and verified by our qualified professionals.

Hypoallergenic Homes is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other affiliate programs. We may earn income when you click on a link. Thank you for helping us deliver the best possible content for our readers.

You May Also Like


Related Articles

Hypoallergenic Hair Sprays
Hypoallergenic Products
Hypoallergenic Homes

Allergy-Free Hairspray: A Guide For Individuals With Hairspray Allergies

If hairspray is a staple in your hair styling routine but you’ve got a sensitive scalp, you may develop allergies to the products you use. Discover whether you have hairspray allergies and your options for allergy-free hairspray products in this article!

hypoallergenic detergent for babies
Hypoallergenic Cleaning
Hypoallergenic Homes

Hypoallergenic Detergent for Babies: Everything You Need to Know

If you want to find the best detergent for babies with sensitive skin, this is the guide for you! There are many substances used in detergent and laundry products which can irritate your bub’s soft skin. Here’s everything you need to know to avoid that from happening to your baby!

Hypoallergenic Products
Hypoallergenic Homes

What Makes a Product Hypoallergenic?

Find out what to look for in the products you buy. How to know your products are really hypoallergenic and won’t cause more allergic reactions.

hypoallergenic socks
Hypoallergenic Products
Hypoallergenic Homes

Hypoallergenic Socks

Find out what causes foot allergies and how hypoallergenic socks can help you get through your day itch-free! Everything you need to know about sock allergies, in one power-packed guide.

Hypoallergenic Homes

Pollen Allergy: Causes, Symptoms and Relief

Pollen allergies affect tens of millions of people each year. Get ahead of the seasonal allergies by identifying pollen allergy symptoms, types, diagnosis and relief treatments today!

hypoallergenic tape
Hypoallergenic Products
Hypoallergenic Homes

Hypoallergenic Tape

Allergic to tape? Sports, medical and fashion tapes can all include irritating ingredients that trigger allergies. This is a guide packed with tips and suggestions for hypoallergenic tape alternatives for sensitive skin!

Hypoallergenic Hand Sanitizer
Hypoallergenic Products
Hypoallergenic Homes

Hypoallergenic Hand Sanitizer: Everything You Need to Know

Hand sanitizers are part of everyday life, but for those with sensitive skin an allergic reaction is far from welcome. Find out what causes allergies to hand sanitizers and explore the hypoallergenic options safe for sensitive skin.

best hypoallergenic bras
Hypoallergenic Products
Hypoallergenic Homes

Allergy-Free Bras: A Guide For Women With Latex Allergies

Allergies to latex, elastic and metals can really get in the way of enjoying a good bra! So women of the world, we have you covered in our guide to hypoallergenic bras suited to everyday comfort.

Your Privacy

We use cookies to enhance your user experience and improve the quality of our website. By continuing to use this website you consent to the use of cookies and agree to our website use Terms of Use.